SUMMARY
The Future
It is not within the scope of this document to address all of the issues raised in Appendix A, however they have been listed to indicate that factors effecting the freshwater fishery are many and varied and that some of the factors may well be beyond the control of any body given primary responsibility for its management. The only way that we will ultimately improve some of these factors is for the wider community to take an active part in addressing these and other related issues an a broad scale.
Any realistic view of the Victorian freshwater fishery will recognise that permanent change has occurred to many if not all of our waterways. It seems very unlikely for instance, that eradication of mosquito fish, if that was seen as a desirable aim, would be possible without doing irreparable collateral damage to the surrounding environment. Also, some exotic fish are important recreational target species, eg trout and redfin, and are the preferred targets for many anglers.
Any management plan for the Victorian freshwater fishery needs to address both the conservation issues for our native species as well as the appropriate management of introduced species. NFA believes that it is possible to satisfy the needs of native fish, both of angling interest and otherwise, and those of economically and recreationally significant exotic fish. NFA would like to see a future where the needs of all anglers are catered for, whilst at the same time Australian Native Fish, although perhaps not restored to their original abundance and distribution, are plentiful in waters not permanently altered so as to be unsuitable and also a future where none of the native fish are endangered. Furthermore NFA would like to foster interest in native fish as targets for recreational anglers and believes that suitable management policies to achieve this end need not and should not interfere with conservation requirements.
NFA acknowledges the valuable work being done in Victoria by Fisheries towards the re-establishment of threatened species to at least part of their former range and to which NFA contributes directly though its native fish breeding program. However, NFA would like to see more resources made available to Fisheries to further expand this work and to also include production of native fish for recreational purposes especially in popular recreational fishing sites such as impoundments.
NFA would not favour the expansion of the trout fishery into waters, especially river systems, not now supporting significant trout populations. NFA opposes further expansion of the trout fishery on two grounds. Firstly given the history of attempted stockings of trout into practically every river system in Victoria, any waters that do not currently support trout seems unlikely to be able to do so, such an effort would appear to be an exercise in futility and a waste of Fisheries resources. Secondly, NFA would oppose such a policy on a more philosophical basis, which is that such a policy would seem to be one that values only trout at the expense of native fishes, either of angling interest or not. It seems that such a policy does not accommodate what NFA believes is the appropriate course where most river systems should be managed primarily as native fish waters, although recognising that many of these waters would still support populations of exotic fish.
Central to this point is the recognition that introduced fish can and do have a detrimental effect upon native populations - these fish need to eat too, and whilst they contribute to the food chain when small (for instance at certain times of year it appears that some populations of Murray cod feed extensively on young carp), they also occupy positions at the top of that chain that would otherwise be occupied by native fish. No fishery can support an infinite number of fish.
NFA believes that whilst the exotic species should never be considered as "naturalised" in this country, any more than rabbits or sheep would be considered as native mammals, there are many waters where it is appropriate to manage introduced species as the valuable recreational resource that they are. Under this policy there would still be significant areas which could be managed as trout waters or as mixed fisheries and there is no reason why the needs of anglers who target trout or other exotic species cannot be met without unduly effecting the overall picture for native fish.
Where to From Here?
Realistically, there can be no return to the conditions that prevailed prior to European settlement. However, significant progress can be made by working together and recognising our largely common interests. NFA stands ready to work with any and all interested parties to secure the future of Victoria's freshwater fishery.
|